Do you have a rule that you really don't like. I do. It's the one about no arguing with my kids. Let me explain.
I have an eighteen year old son, senior in high school. Some of you probably already are sympathetic already, knowing what it is like. Yet some of you, have these wonderful, innocent young kids that still think you are the smartest and most wonderful person ever. You may not want to read this post if you don't want to know what the future holds for you.
My husband makes this rule about no arguing with the kids. He says that the reasoning behind the rule is that the child should not be arguing with me, it is disrespectful. Also that it causes disharmony in the house.
So today, my son starts spewing this nonsense about how women make terrible bosses and that they should just do their job, staying home taking care of the house and children. Yes, that is what I do but no I don't do it because I would make a bad boss. He is frustrated with the head life guard that he will be working under. He didn't want the job in the first place, plus she has already been trained and she has been there longer than him. But he isn't happy. (Did I mention that he also has dated the girl). So to him, this girl is not competant to be his boss and thus all women are incapable of being in charge, being the boss.
How am I supposed to react? I begin by giving him history lessons, facts and evidence trying to show him the error of way of thinking. He is just being obstinate and wanting to argue. I don't want to argue I just want him to know the truth and to understand that he is not correct.
Guess who called right in the height of our conversation. Yep, my husband. I tell him how his son is being sexist and isn't listening to me. My husband says that I am arguing with him. That I am not supposed to get into these kind of conversations because it is a no win kind of thing and it just gets me upset. I tell him I am not arguing, I am trying to educate. My husband is not in agreement.
When I go back out to the kitchen, my son apologizes and said that he should not have said the things that he had. He admits that he was wrong and that he should not have been so disrespectful.
Too late for me, I am already in trouble. I hate this rule. I have a hard time not telling my children that their way of thinking is illogical. I know, it wouldn't matter anyway, he still thinks that he is smarter than me and his dad. But a debate isn't really an argument is it?




Nope..a debate is not an argument, so you shouldn't be in trouble. That's my "non-hoh" line of thinking..lol.
ReplyDeleteI have rules I don't like, and very strict ones related how I act around the children. I do run into a wall on it sometimes, and HE IS THE WALL.
On the other hand, if you had not engaged him, he probably would have come around and apologized anyway. Boys need time to process, it seems.
Hope you didn't get in really bad hot water over it.
Thanks! Dang I hate that word engage. My husband thinks that way too. When J, my son, is in one of his moods, it's like he wants to argue "debate" with me. The child should be a lawyer, he is smart and quick thinking. But he also knows which buttons of mine to push. If I just didn't let him "engage" me, then maybe things wouldn't get heated. Yes, I am in trouble. That is one of our very few rules.
DeleteBlondie my friend,
ReplyDeleteA debate is not an argument. You do not need to tolerate your son being disrespectful to you, it's good he apologized and was "just spouting off". Not feeling backed up in front of the kids is my number 1 issue. We definitely struggle with the parenting stuff at times but we don't let the kids play u.
Laurie
Thanks Laurie. If my kids knew what was said between my husband and myself regarding our kids, they would have a field day. In front of the kids, we are a united front. There has been so much turbulence in our house in the past that we really had to change things. I think if J knew that I got in trouble for 'debating" things with him, that he would be furious with his dad. He was mad about one thing and decided to make generalized statements that he knows would get to me - I was raised by a feminist speaker... Since we have been doing ttwd though, my husband has been fantastic with backing me up even when he doesn't agree. I just can't get into a "debate" where there is a lot of emotions and frustration. I should have just let him spill and not let him get a rise out of me. Oh well...
DeleteActually, I am impressed with your boy for apologizing to you, like he should have.
ReplyDeleteI understand what your husband is getting at. To argue brings you down to his level. As he grows into adulthood, you'll have plenty of debates, and you'll need to show respectful acceptance of his right to think what he wants, while expressing your own views.
As to the rule between your husband and you, that's hard to address. TTWD is so different with each couple. This is not an offense we have at our home, but if it were a recurring issue that increased tension, I might make a rule about how Lynda behaves during this moment.
Mine is graduating too. Congratulations on raising him to reach this important point in his life.
Mick, yeah that is what my husban says about "going down to his level" and all that. My son is smart and very quick thinking, like my husband. J, my son, is a great kid but I think that all the stuff that is going on his life right now is causing him a lot of stress. The reason for the rule is that I am emotional and upset and I can fall right into the old ways of acting his age which means that there is no line between parent and child. Thus the rule. Kids don't know anythng about this rule or ttwd. Since we started it though, my husband and myself have become a team with the parenting. The kids are seeing us as one. And my husband wants the kids to listen and respect me as much as they do him.
DeleteCongratulations with your son graduating. Time goes by so fast.
Blondie,
ReplyDeleteWhen we have children in this house (and I say when and not if b/c I choose to believe), you are all going to need to have my back. I'm going to be in trouble a lot!
I also like that he apologized to you and I would have an awfully hard time not engaging with a teenager who needed his thoughts on women straightened out a little.
Susie, God gives us babies who become toddlers, who then become sweet little adoring kids, before they become teenagers. When I am about ready to strangle one of mine, I just pull out the photo albums and look at their old pictures. Saves the teen every time.
DeleteHe is a really good kid, just knows how to engage me in an (dare I say) argument.
I noticed that most of the time my kids were spouting something I knew to be unreasonable they just needed to vent - they usually knew deep down that they were over stating something or just plain wrong, but they needed me as a sounding board. I'd just tell them that I could tell that they were frustrated and that I disagreed with them.
ReplyDeleteI'm always up for a good spanking, but I think spirited debates with your kids is a wonderful way to make them think through their side of the discussion. I remember 'arguing' with my day and often going to school and taking the position he had taken because he made so much sense. And you 18 year old sounds like a well raised kid!
Hugs,
PK
PK Thanks! He is a great kid. And you are right, he was just spouting off. But instead of sticking to what was wrong, he attacked (verbally) me. And I fell for it, hook, line and sinker. If I just stuck to the facts and didn't get emotionally involved, my husband would not consider it an argument. That is when I have lowered myself to his level and I lose their respect. He is so smart and thinks quick. But watch out when he is mad about something.
DeleteIt is just one off our only real rules and it is set up to help. Sometimes I just really hate it because I feel so mad at myself for getting emotionally involved and also my husband knowing that I did it.
I love a good spanking too. But hate the punishment ones because they mean that I messed up. Yuck
Blondie - it sounded like a debate to me. Each side presenting their own view.
ReplyDeleteI don't know the whole story but if your son could hear your conversation with his dad, I think your husband was wrong. He should be supportive of you so you present a unified front. If he had an issue he should take it up with you in private. If that was the case, to me he was being disrespectful to you.
The fact you got an apology says volumes of how he was raised. Congratulations.
Sunnygirl, if my husband was home, he definitely would have backed me up and probably calmed things down. He and I always present a united front, it is the very best thing that has come from ttwd. He told me over the phone and by text that I was in trouble. My kids would never know that this is even a rule. He is a great kid and I am very proud of him. But when I let him get to me personally and not keep things factual, it is no longer a debate but an argument. If I argue with him or his siblings, I lose their respect. I hate if that I didn't just let him vent and not got involved. But this son of mine knows my buttons. Our debates are great, he is very smart. But to keep things calm in our house, I am really trying to keep things in order and to be the parent. Don't worry my husband will back me up in front of the kids even if he thinks I am wrong. We will discuss it later if need be, and I can change my mind if I want to but he never undermines me in the parenting.
DeleteAh I also have to 'not argue' with my children, but, debates, and guidance, are different. Very glad your son apologised. That takes a certain maturity :)
ReplyDeleteDee x
Dee, I am glad that I am not the only one. It really did go farther than a debate because emotions were involved. He just knew what to say to push my buttons. He was mad about one thing and dealt with it this way. He and I are very close and I know how lucky I am to have him trust me and talk to me. My sixteen year old is very private and when he speaks, his one liners, it is to complain about something, or he needs a ride, wants to borrow money or he is hungry. I just need to always remember not to take things personally
DeleteOh goodness, I'm glad this isn't a rule for me. Having said that, my teenage daughter also knows quite well how to push my buttons and I have been told by Michael to cease and desist before. It can be aggravating all the way around, that's for sure.
ReplyDeleteGrace, cease and desist I hear that a lot too when my husband is around. He just happened to call in the middle of the heated part of our (argument) debate. When he makes his sexist comments, I become my mother's daughter (my mom is a paid feminist speaker) and he irritates me and I just want to shake some sense into him. He knows it too. I fell for it and got caught. Dang!
DeleteI have a similar rule about snapping at my girls. When they are fighting with one another I just can't help it. I don't particularly like that rule. I am a single mom with them full time and I often feel judged when Daddy get's upset with me about it. I usually spout off at the mouth about seeing how he will handle it when he's around it 24/7 but as you can imagine that only makes the punishment worse. At the end of the day I know he's right but I still hate it when he makes me apologize to the kids.
ReplyDeleteSounds to me like you were debating, I think you should try and debate yourself out of that punishment for sure.
dancingbarez, I know exactly what you mean here.
DeleteDee x
I tried to debate myself out of the spanking. No such luck. My son knows exactly how to bait me into an argument. Debates are fine but arguing with them whether it is about politics are cleaning their room is just not okay. I use to be a pushover with the kids so we are changing that. I am not to argue with them, what I say is final and then my husband will back me up. Unfortunately, my husband called right in the middle of it and I did the "YOUR SON" thing. Not such a good idea. The kids listen to him better than me so I do feel like he is critical of me when he tells me how I should have handled the situation. I am with them 24/7 too. Thanks for your support.
DeleteHaving an 18-yr-old son myself, Blondie, I know how quickly a debate can turn into an argument. After all, they know EVERYTHING. :)
ReplyDeleteWords of wisdom I received from a friend, "A one-sided argument is no fun". If my son is becoming disrespectful, I just turn around and walk away. He understands why now, but the first time I did that, the look on his face was pretty comical.
Now when he comes to me "need to talk, mom" I let him vent and he is much more receptive to my ideas and opinions. I've noticed that he will tell his girlfriend that there is "no need to take that tone with me, if you want to talk, we can talk".
I can see where no arguing with the children is a good/bad thing as a rule, but I'm sorry you got spanked. :(
Great advice, I should have called you before my husband called and found out that I was having it out with my son. Dang it! I am sorry that I got in trouble too. Bottom is very, very sore. :(.
DeleteBlondie, We have almost the same rule here.
ReplyDeleteMy oldest daughter is 16. "H" hates it if we begin to argue, and then text... She will stomp off to her room and I will be downstairs and we will begin the fight all over again through texting.
Drives "H" crazy because I get so upset, and he feels we should talk face to face, but also - not to get too into the fight. He says it's hiding and acting on her level.
I have been spanked twice for issues between me and my teen. They REALLY know how to push buttons!
Sounds like yours was more debate - but then again, your husband may see it another way! :) Sorry to hear you were spanked for it.
Emi, can you imagine if our children knew what happens when we argue with them. I could see my 16 year old plotting right now. It really does cause tension in the house and I wish that I didn't always want to help him and teach him right from wrong.
DeleteButt yeah, my husband truly wants the arguing to end. He wants the children to respect me and he is determined to make sure that it happens. My poor bottom really hurts. I would rather have the good girl spanking anyday
Blondie,
ReplyDeleteI don't have teenagers, but I was one. I remember telling my parents many times "But, I'm 18" and that was the answer to just about any question. Ha. But, on the serious side, Yuk if you get punished. As others have said...nice your son apologized. That means he has a great Mom who has taught hime well :o). I read this before I left for work, but I did not have time to comment. Looks like lots of other Mom's are in your corner by the comments above. Regards,
Thanks SNP, I remember being eighteen and hating thatt my parents were so strict and would never listen to me. So I think that I let them argue their points too much. My son was just letting steam off and I let him get to me. Thanks for the compliment. Yes there was a spanking and I hate those kind of spankings. Hopefully I will be even more careful in the future.
DeleteUh oh...and here I thought my 5-year-old already knew how to push my buttons! I'm sure this is something that I am going to have to be careful with as my kiddos get older. It must be so hard to take a step back and not get sucked into an argument when they are insisting they are right, and you KNOW they could stand to be enlightened about a thing or two. It's sweet how your son came around on his own and apologized:)
ReplyDeleteAhhhh Tess, they all have their moments, good and bad. I am such a sucker when it comes to arguimg with him. He is a great kid and he would never want to hurt my feelings, but he is just a kid. Gotta love him :)
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteDebating, arguing, debating arguing. Such a fine line. They do think they have all the answers sometimes don't they? Him apologizing to you says a lot about him. Sorry that you ended up in trouble over it.
ReplyDeleteZoe, so true - it is a fine line. Parenting can be such a mixture of lines that are blurred. He is a good kid and I am glad that so many people took note of that, because I typed that comment about him apologizing without even thinking that what he was doing was really a great thing. Now I will appreciate it more when he does things like that.
Delete